FCPS Paediatrics TOACS Β· Interactive Station

🩺 Nail Biting – Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior (BFRB), Habit Reversal Training (HRT), Onychophagia, Differential Diagnosis (Trichotillomania, Excoriation Disorder, OCD, Tic Disorders), Psychosocial Management πŸ“š Paeds Online – paeds.online
βš•οΈ OBSERVED STATION Β· CPSP FORMAT Β· 8 MINUTES Β· SEPARATE TABS Β· CLINICAL SCENARIO
πŸ“– Problem-oriented Clinical Scenario – Severe Nail Biting
πŸ‘§πŸ» Clinical Scenario (read aloud – 2 min):

A 14-year-old girl is brought to your pediatric clinic by her mother with concerns about nail biting that has become progressively worse over the past 2 years. The patient reports that she bites her nails until they bleed, and her cuticles are often red, swollen, and occasionally infected. She has tried bitter-tasting nail polish without success. She describes feeling tension or an urge before biting, and a sense of relief or gratification after biting. She also bites the skin around her nails (cuticles) and sometimes bites her lips. She is embarrassed about the appearance of her hands and hides them in her pockets. She has no other compulsive behaviors or tics. Her mother is frustrated and asks: "Why won't she stop? We've tried everything. Is this just a bad habit, or is there something wrong?"

Task for the candidate: You are the pediatrician. Discuss your approach to this patient. Identify whether this is a habit versus a disorder (Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior – BFRB). Discuss the differential diagnosis (trichotillomania, excoriation disorder, tic disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder). Describe the treatment approach, including Habit Reversal Training (HRT), competing response, and when to refer to a mental health specialist. The examiner will observe your response and ask follow-up questions.
πŸ’‘ Examiner instruction (interactive): This is a case of chronic nail biting (onychophagia) with tissue damage. The key features: (1) repetitive behavior causing physical damage (bleeding, infection), (2) unsuccessful attempts to stop (bitter polish failed), (3) presence of premonitory urge and relief after biting (suggests a repetitive behavior disorder), (4) embarrassment and avoidance. The candidate should: (a) recognize that this is not a simple habit but a Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior (BFRB) that may meet criteria for Other Specified Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorder (or Unspecified), (b) differentiate from tic disorders, OCD, trichotillomania, excoriation disorder, (c) assess for comorbid anxiety, depression, or ADHD, (d) recommend Habit Reversal Training (HRT) as first-line treatment, (e) discuss competing response (e.g., clenching fists, squeezing a ball), (f) manage secondary infections, and (g) refer to a therapist specializing in BFRBs if severe.
πŸ” Examiner Questions (interactive) – Click to reveal model answers
❓ Q1 (Examiner): β€œIs this girl's nail biting a simple habit or a disorder? What factors indicate this is clinically significant?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ This is NOT a simple habit – it is a clinically significant Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior (BFRB).
β€’ Factors indicating clinical significance:
1️⃣ Tissue damage – bleeding, infection of cuticles (beyond minor cosmetic concerns).
2️⃣ Multiple unsuccessful attempts to stop – bitter polish, willpower alone (she has tried).
3️⃣ Presence of premonitory urge and relief – tension before, relief/gratification after (characteristic of BFRBs).
4️⃣ Functional impairment – embarrassment, hiding hands, social avoidance.
5️⃣ Duration >2 years – chronic, not transient.
β€’ DSM-5 classification: While nail biting alone does not have a specific code, this presentation could be diagnosed as Other Specified Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorder (Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior). It is distinct from trichotillomania (hair pulling) and excoriation (skin picking), but clinically similar.
β€’ Differential includes habit (no distress/impairment) vs BFRB (distress, impairment, tissue damage).
❓ Q2 (Examiner): β€œWhat are Body-Focused Repetitive Behaviors (BFRBs)? List the most common types and their DSM-5 classifications.”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ BFRBs: Repetitive, self-grooming behaviors that cause damage to the body. They are characterized by a premonitory urge before the behavior and relief or gratification during/after.
β€’ Common BFRBs and DSM-5 classification:
- Trichotillomania (Hair-Pulling Disorder) – recurrent pulling out of one's hair, resulting in hair loss. DSM-5 diagnosis.
- Excoriation (Skin-Picking) Disorder – recurrent skin picking resulting in lesions. DSM-5 diagnosis.
- Onychophagia (Nail biting) – not a standalone diagnosis in DSM-5; classified under Other Specified Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorder (or Unspecified) if causing clinically significant distress/impairment.
- Cheek biting, lip biting, tongue chewing – also BFRBs.
β€’ This patient has nail biting with tissue damage and functional impairment – meets criteria for a BFRB diagnosis.
β€’ BFRBs are distinct from tics (no premonitory urge? – actually tics also have premonitory urges) and from OCD (no obsessions).
❓ Q3 (Examiner): β€œWhat is the differential diagnosis for chronic nail biting? How would you distinguish BFRB from tic disorders and OCD?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Differential diagnosis:
1️⃣ Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior (BFRB) – repetitive grooming behavior; premonitory urge + relief; no obsession; ego-syntonic (feels "right" to do).
2️⃣ Tic disorders (Tourette, chronic motor tic) – sudden, rapid, recurrent, non-rhythmic movements (e.g., eye blinking, neck jerking). Premonitory urge also present. Tics are typically less focused on grooming and can involve vocalizations. Nail biting is not typically classified as a tic.
3️⃣ Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) – repetitive behaviors (compulsions) performed to neutralize obsessions (e.g., fear of contamination). Compulsions are ego-dystonic (unwanted, resisted). No premonitory urge/relief cycle. Nail biting in OCD would be driven by an obsession (e.g., "my nails must be perfectly smooth") – not typical.
4️⃣ Stereotypic movement disorder – repetitive, rhythmic, purposeless movements (e.g., hand flapping, body rocking) in neurodevelopmental disorders. Not this.
5️⃣ Self-injurious behavior (non-suicidal self-injury) – intentional harm to cope with negative emotions, but different intent and context.
6️⃣ Habit (normal) – no tissue damage, no distress, no impairment.
β€’ This patient's presentation (urge + relief, tissue damage, embarrassment) is most consistent with BFRB.
❓ Q4 (Examiner): β€œWhat additional history would you obtain from this patient to assess for comorbid conditions and triggers?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Function of the behavior (triggers):
- "What feelings or situations make you bite your nails more?" (boredom, stress, anxiety, concentration).
- "Do you feel a tension or urge before biting?" (premonitory urge).
- "Do you feel relief during or after biting?"
- "Are you aware of the behavior while doing it?" (automatic vs focused).
β€’ Comorbid psychiatric symptoms:
- Anxiety disorders – excessive worry, social anxiety (hiding hands).
- Depression – low mood, anhedonia.
- ADHD – impulsivity, difficulty stopping habits.
- OCD – other rituals, obsessions, compulsions.
- Tic disorders – other motor or vocal tics.
- Trichotillomania, excoriation – pulling hair, picking skin elsewhere.
β€’ Family history: BFRBs, tics, OCD, anxiety.
β€’ Past treatments: What worked? What failed? (bitter polish, fidget toys, rewards).
β€’ Functional impact: School performance, social relationships (peers noticing), avoidance behaviors.
β€’ Rule out organic causes: Neurologic exam (rule out tics, chorea, dystonia).
❓ Q5 (Examiner): β€œWhat is a premonitory urge? Why is it important to recognize in BFRBs and tic disorders?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Premonitory urge: An unpleasant bodily sensation, tension, or feeling that precedes and triggers the repetitive behavior (nail biting, tic, hair pulling, skin picking). The behavior is performed to relieve the urge.
β€’ Characteristics:
- Patients describe it as "building tension" or "itch" that must be relieved.
- The behavior provides temporary relief or gratification.
- This distinguishes BFRBs/tic disorders from habits or OCD (where compulsions are driven by obsessions, not sensory urges).
β€’ Importance in treatment:
- Habit Reversal Training (HRT) teaches the patient to recognize the premonitory urge and perform a competing response (an alternative behavior that is incompatible with nail biting) when the urge occurs.
- This is the first-line behavioral treatment for BFRBs and tics.
- This patient described urge before biting β†’ good candidate for HRT.
❓ Q6 (Examiner): β€œWhat is Habit Reversal Training (HRT)? Describe the key components and how it would be applied to nail biting.”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Habit Reversal Training (HRT) – evidence-based treatment for BFRBs and tic disorders.
β€’ Key components (applied to nail biting):
1️⃣ Increased awareness (Response description and detection):
- Patient describes the nail-biting behavior in detail.
- Patient identifies each time the nail-biting occurs (self-monitoring).
2️⃣ Identifying premonitory urge:
- Patient recognizes the tension/urge that precedes biting.
- Early warning: "I feel my finger moving toward my mouth."
3️⃣ Competing response:
- Patient is taught an incompatible behavior to perform when the urge is felt.
- For nail biting: clench fists for 1-2 minutes, squeeze a stress ball, put hands in pockets, or press palms together until the urge passes.
- The competing response must be physically incompatible with nail biting.
4️⃣ Relaxation training: Deep breathing to reduce overall anxiety.
5️⃣ Social support: Parents/peers provide praise when competing response is used.
6️⃣ Generalization training: Practice in various situations (home, school, boredom, stress).
β€’ Efficacy: HRT is highly effective (>70-80% reduction in symptoms) for BFRBs.
β€’ This patient should be referred to a psychologist for HRT.
❓ Q7 (Examiner): β€œGive specific examples of competing responses for nail biting. Why must the competing response be physically incompatible?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Competing responses for nail biting:
1️⃣ Clench fists – squeeze tightly for 1 minute (cannot bite nails while clenching).
2️⃣ Place hands under thighs or in pockets.
3️⃣ Squeeze a stress ball or fidget toy.
4️⃣ Press palms together firmly.
5️⃣ Interlock fingers and rest them on the lap.
6️⃣ Hold a smooth stone or worry stone.
7️⃣ Apply bitter-tasting polish (as an adjunct, but not effective alone).
β€’ Why physically incompatible? The competing response must physically prevent the nail-biting behavior. If the response is not incompatible (e.g., just thinking about not biting), it will not work. The muscle movement of the competing response substitutes for the habitual movement.
β€’ The patient must practice the competing response multiple times daily when NOT biting, so it becomes automatic when the urge occurs.
β€’ Duration: Competing response should be performed for 1-2 minutes or until the urge subsides.
❓ Q8 (Examiner): β€œThe patient has tried bitter nail polish without success. Why did it fail? Is it ever helpful?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Why bitter polish failed (common):
- It targets the consequence (aversive taste) rather than the antecedent (premonitory urge).
- Many patients continue biting despite the taste, or they become desensitized to the taste over time.
- Does not address the underlying urge or provide a competing behavior.
β€’ Is bitter polish ever helpful?
- May be useful as an adjunct to HRT (provides an extra deterrent).
- May work for mild, automatic nail biting (without premonitory urge) in younger children.
- For this patient (severe, with urge, tissue damage), bitter polish alone is insufficient – she needs HRT.
β€’ Recommend using bitter polish together with HRT, not as a standalone treatment.
❓ Q9 (Examiner): β€œIs there a role for medication in treating nail biting? If so, what medications and when?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ No FDA-approved medications specifically for nail biting or BFRBs.
β€’ Medications are used to treat comorbid conditions that may exacerbate nail biting:
- Anxiety disorders (GAD, social anxiety) – SSRIs (fluoxetine, sertraline) may reduce overall anxiety, which may reduce nail biting as a secondary effect.
- ADHD – stimulants may reduce impulsivity, but can worsen tics/BFRBs in some; alpha-agonists (guanfacine) may help.
- Tic disorders – alpha-agonists (guanfacine, clonidine) may reduce tics and BFRBs.
β€’ N-acetylcysteine (NAC): An amino acid that has shown some benefit in trichotillomania and skin picking (small studies). Limited evidence for nail biting. Dose: 1200-2400 mg/day. May be tried as adjunct.
β€’ Do NOT use benzodiazepines (risk of dependence) or antipsychotics unless severe tic disorder or aggression.
β€’ This patient should first try HRT. If comorbid anxiety is present, treat the anxiety with CBT/SSRI; nail biting may improve as a secondary benefit.
❓ Q10 (Examiner): β€œThis patient has infected cuticles (paronychia). How would you manage the medical complications?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Paronychia management:
- Mild (no abscess): Warm soaks (2-3 times daily), topical antibiotic (mupirocin or bacitracin).
- Moderate (purulent discharge, erythema): Oral antibiotics (cephalexin or clindamycin) for 7-10 days. Cover for Staph and Strep.
- Abscess formation: Incision and drainage by a dermatologist or surgeon.
β€’ Preventive measures:
- Moisturize cuticles with petroleum jelly or lotion to prevent cracking.
- Keep nails trimmed short (but not too short) to reduce temptation.
- Wear gloves or bandages on fingers to break the habit (temporary).
- Treat underlying BFRB with HRT to prevent recurrence.
β€’ Consider dermatology referral if recurrent infections or severe tissue damage.
- Screen for immunocompromise (unlikely in this patient).
❓ Q11 (Examiner): β€œWhat psychiatric comorbidities are common in adolescents with severe BFRBs? Why is it important to screen for them?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Common comorbidities:
- Anxiety disorders (generalized anxiety, social anxiety) – 30-50% comorbidity.
- Depression – due to shame, embarrassment, social avoidance.
- OCD – some overlap, but distinct.
- ADHD – impulsivity contributes to difficulty stopping.
- Tic disorders – co-occurrence common.
- Trichotillomania, excoriation disorder – other BFRBs.
β€’ Why screen?
- Untreated comorbidity (e.g., anxiety) may perpetuate the BFRB.
- Treatment of anxiety with CBT/SSRI may improve nail biting as secondary benefit.
- BFRB may be a marker for underlying emotional dysregulation.
- This patient should be screened using validated tools (PHQ-9 for depression, SCARED for anxiety, Vanderbilt for ADHD).
❓ Q12 (Examiner): β€œThis patient hides her hands and is embarrassed. What psychosocial impact does nail biting have on adolescents?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Psychosocial impact of severe nail biting:
- Social embarrassment and shame – peers may tease or stare at the damaged nails.
- Avoidance behaviors – hiding hands, avoiding handshakes, wearing gloves or long sleeves in warm weather.
- Impaired self-esteem and body image.
- Academic impact – difficulty writing or typing if pain present; distraction in class.
- Social isolation – avoiding activities where hands are visible (sports, music, art).
- Family conflict – parents frustrated by inability to stop.
- Risk of depression and anxiety due to chronic shame.
β€’ This patient's embarrassment and hiding hands indicate significant functional impairment.
β€’ Intervention (HRT) can improve both the behavior and the psychosocial consequences.
❓ Q13 (Examiner): β€œHow will you counsel the mother who is frustrated and asks, β€˜Why won’t she just stop? Is this just a bad habit?’”
βœ… Candidate's structured answer:
β€’ β€œI understand your frustration. Many parents ask the same question. Your daughter is not doing this on purpose to upset you.”
β€’ β€œThis is not just a bad habit. It is a condition called a Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior. She feels a building tension or urge before biting, and the biting temporarily relieves that urge. She has tried to stop but cannot on her own – that is part of the disorder.”
β€’ β€œBlaming her or nagging her will not help and may increase her shame and anxiety, which can actually worsen the behavior.”
β€’ β€œThe good news is that there is an effective treatment called Habit Reversal Training. A therapist will teach her to recognize the urge and do a competing behavior (like clenching her fists) instead of biting.”
β€’ β€œYou can help by praising her when you see her using the competing behavior, and by creating a calm, low-stress environment. Do not punish her for biting – that only increases anxiety.”
β€’ β€œWe also need to treat any underlying anxiety or depression, which may be contributing. I will screen her for those conditions.”
β€’ β€œWith proper treatment, she can learn to control this. It is not her fault, and it is not a lack of willpower.”
❓ Q14 (Examiner): β€œWould you manage this patient in primary care or refer to a mental health specialist? What are the indications for referral?”
βœ… Candidate's answer:
β€’ Refer to a mental health specialist (psychologist or psychiatrist) with experience in BFRBs and Habit Reversal Training.
β€’ Indications for referral (this patient qualifies):
1️⃣ Severe tissue damage – bleeding, infection, significant physical harm.
2️⃣ Failed simple behavioral measures – bitter polish, parental reminders have failed.
3️⃣ Functional impairment – embarrassment, hiding hands, social avoidance.
4️⃣ Presence of premonitory urge and relief – indicates BFRB that requires HRT.
5️⃣ Possible comorbid psychiatric conditions – screen for anxiety, depression, tics, OCD.
6️⃣ Symptoms persisting >1 year despite attempts to stop.
β€’ Can primary care manage? Primary care can:
- Provide initial education and reassurance.
- Screen for comorbidities.
- Treat medical complications (paronychia).
- Recommend over-the-counter deterrents (bitter polish) as a trial.
- But for severe cases with tissue damage and functional impairment, referral to a therapist for HRT is the standard of care.
- This patient needs referral to a psychologist for HRT.
πŸ—£οΈ Examiner's probing / high-yield points (Nail Biting – BFRB):
β€’ "What is the most concerning feature of this case?" β†’ Tissue damage (bleeding, infection) and functional impairment (embarrassment).
β€’ "What is the first-line treatment?" β†’ Habit Reversal Training (HRT).
β€’ "What is a competing response for nail biting?" β†’ Clench fists, squeeze a ball, put hands in pockets.
β€’ "What is a premonitory urge?" β†’ Tension or urge that precedes the behavior; relief after performing the behavior.
β€’ "Is bitter nail polish effective?" β†’ Often fails alone; may be used as adjunct to HRT.
β€’ "Is this a tic disorder?" β†’ No – tics are sudden, rapid movements (eye blinking, neck jerking). Nail biting is a BFRB.
β€’ "When to refer to mental health?" β†’ Severe tissue damage, functional impairment, failed simple measures.
πŸ“˜ Nail Biting (Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior) – Core Revision for TOACS
πŸ” Definition
Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior (BFRB): repetitive self-grooming behavior causing tissue damage. Includes onychophagia (nail biting), trichotillomania (hair pulling), excoriation (skin picking).
🩺 Clinical Features
Premonitory urge (tension before behavior), relief/gratification during/after, tissue damage (bleeding, infection), embarrassment, avoidance, failed attempts to stop.
πŸ“‹ Differential Diagnosis
Tic disorders (sudden, rapid movements, vocalizations), OCD (compulsions driven by obsessions, ego-dystonic), habit (no distress/impairment), self-injurious behavior.
πŸ’Š First-Line Treatment
Habit Reversal Training (HRT): awareness training, identifying premonitory urge, competing response (e.g., clench fists, squeeze ball), relaxation, social support. Highly effective.
πŸ”ͺ Pharmacotherapy
No FDA-approved medications for BFRBs. Treat comorbid conditions (anxiety β†’ SSRI; ADHD β†’ stimulants/alpha-agonists). N-acetylcysteine (NAC) 1200-2400 mg/day may help (limited evidence).
πŸ“ˆ Prognosis
With HRT, >70-80% improvement. Comorbid anxiety/depression worsens prognosis. Early referral to therapist improves outcomes.
⭐ High-yield pearls for TOACS (Nail Biting – BFRB):
β€’ Tissue damage + failed attempts + premonitory urge = BFRB, not simple habit.
β€’ First-line treatment = Habit Reversal Training (competing response: clench fists, squeeze ball).
β€’ Bitter nail polish is often ineffective alone (adjunct to HRT).
β€’ Premonitory urge = tension before behavior; relief after = key feature.
β€’ Differentiate from tic disorders (sudden, rapid movements) and OCD (obsessions).
β€’ Refer to psychologist for HRT if severe, tissue damage, functional impairment.
β€’ Treat medical complications (paronychia) with warm soaks, topical/oral antibiotics.
πŸ—£οΈ Candidate's role-play & examiner feedback
πŸ’¬ To the candidate (role‑play): You will be asked the 14 questions from the Examiner Q&A tab. This station tests knowledge of nail biting as a Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior (BFRB) – recognizing when a habit becomes a disorder (tissue damage, functional impairment, failed attempts, premonitory urge). The first-line treatment is Habit Reversal Training (HRT) with competing responses (clenching fists, squeezing a ball). The candidate should differentiate BFRB from tic disorders and OCD, manage medical complications (paronychia), and refer to a mental health specialist for HRT. Provide empathetic counseling to the frustrated mother – explain that this is not a lack of willpower and that blaming increases anxiety and worsens the behavior.
πŸ“ Examiner Marking Grid (Nail Biting – BFRB – TOACS station):
  • βœ… Recognizes that this is not a simple habit – it is a Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior (BFRB) with clinical significance
  • βœ… Identifies key features: tissue damage (bleeding, infection), failed attempts (bitter polish), premonitory urge, relief, embarrassment
  • βœ… Distinguishes BFRB from tic disorders (sudden, rapid movements) and OCD (obsessions, ego-dystonic)
  • βœ… Describes premonitory urge and its role in Habit Reversal Training
  • βœ… Recommends Habit Reversal Training (HRT) as first-line evidence-based treatment
  • βœ… Provides specific competing responses for nail biting (clench fists, squeeze a stress ball, put hands in pockets)
  • βœ… States that bitter nail polish is often ineffective alone (adjunct to HRT at best)
  • βœ… Discusses medical management of paronychia (warm soaks, topical/oral antibiotics)
  • βœ… Screens for comorbid anxiety, depression, ADHD, tics, trichotillomania
  • βœ… Counsels mother empathetically (not her daughter's fault, not a lack of willpower, effective treatment available) and refers to psychologist
πŸ“š Key references: Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics 22e (Chapter 37 – Motor Disorders and Habits), American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines for Body-Focused Repetitive Behaviors, Habit Reversal Training literature, CPSP protocols for behavioral disorders.